Sarah's Pizza

Located in the heart of West Alexandria, Ohio, Sarah's Pizza is a beloved local gem specializing in crave-worthy pizza, meal delivery, and takeaway options that keep customers coming back time and again. Whether you’re craving a comforting slice or an entire pie with a unique twist, Sarah’s Pizza delivers a heartfelt culinary experience that blends fresh ingredients with a flair for bold flavors.

At the center of Sarah’s menu is their signature Buffalo Chicken Pizza, which perfectly balances spicy, zesty buffalo sauce with tender chicken atop a golden, freshly baked crust. For health-conscious diners and those with dietary restrictions, Sarah’s remarkable cauliflower crust stands out — gluten-free and packed with flavor. As Amy Dillon praises, it’s a delicious option that truly accommodates those with Celiac Disease without compromising on taste or texture.

The aroma of freshly made dough — light and airy with just the right hint of saltiness — envelops the restaurant and takes you to a cozy neighborhood pizzeria where quality and care are top priorities. John Durham’s vivid description of their dough, breadsticks, and subs captures this perfectly; it’s “simply to die for,” elevating every bite into an indulgence that triggers nostalgia and comfort.

Beyond pizza, Sarah's Pizza offers customer favorites like their inventive mashed potato pizza, a unique creation that has earned acclaim and satisfied curious palates. Jennifer Howell highlights the variety, mentioning everything from rib tips to cheese ravioli, revealing a menu with depth and range for the adventurous eater. The fast and reliable delivery service further enhances their appeal, offering convenience without sacrificing taste or quality.

One testament to Sarah’s commitment to customer satisfaction is their attentive staff, who strive to make every order smooth and complete — with a human touch, even when technology falls short, as Sarah Lewis’s experience reflects. This dedication to ensuring a positive interaction makes Sarah's Pizza much more than just a quick meal; it’s a trusted part of the community.

If you find yourself in West Alexandria and crave pizza that bursts with flavor, comfort, and a touch of creative flair, Sarah’s Pizza awaits with open doors and piping hot pies that feel like home on every plate.